Raise your hand if you're smarter than John Dorsey and Andy Reid

[Imon Yourside]

Originally Posted by Peyton's Princess

we got the best QB prospect in this draft at #34

not bad

He compares well with Cassel, I guess I did my best but my best wasn't good enough is appropriate?

[Hootie]

Originally Posted by KILLER_CLOWN

He compares well with Cassel, I guess I did my best but my best wasn't good enough is appropriate?

Alex Smith is to Matt Cassel as Trent Green is to Rick Mirer.

[milkman]

Originally Posted by Peyton's Princess

Alex Smith is to Matt Cassel as Trent Green is to Rick Mirer.

In this comparison, David Carr is a better example as a comparison to Trent Green.

[Hootie]

Originally Posted by milkman

In this comparison, David Carr is a better example as a comparison to Trent Green.

I was just thinking on the go.

I understand the not being excited for Alex Smith or for Eric Fisher sentiment...100%. Neither of them excited me, either.

But I'm not unrealistic, and I'm certainly not going to say Alex Smith compares to Matt Cassel.

That's ludicrous.

[Imon Yourside]

Originally Posted by Peyton's Princess

Alex Smith is to Matt Cassel as Trent Green is to Rick Mirer.

The career stats speak differently, Cassel actually has better stats. I REALLY hope that I'm wrong.

[Hootie]

Originally Posted by KILLER_CLOWN

The career stats speak differently, Cassel actually has better stats. I REALLY hope that I'm wrong.

dumbest argument out there

actually

it's really ****ing stupid

I'd elaborate, but I fear you're too stupid to comprehend.

[whoman69]

The number one pick is supposed to be an impact player. It seems like we're just making a lateral move.

[Hootie]

Originally Posted by whoman69

The number one pick is supposed to be an impact player. It seems like we're just making a lateral move.

was Willie Roaf an impact player?

Look, I didn't want a tackle 1st overall. No way.

but after I watched the first round...

I realized that was honestly the only way to go. Or Dion Jordan. Whatever.

There was no elite QB and no elite WR. So oh well.

Everyone but ChiefsPlanet agrees the Chiefs made the right pick. These are the same experts that promised everyone Geno wasn't elite. Seems like they are smarter than SNR and Milkman. They get paid, there is a reason for it.

[SAUTO]

Originally Posted by Peyton's Princess

was Willie Roaf an impact player?

Look, I didn't want a tackle 1st overall. No way.

but after I watched the first round...

I realized that was honestly the only way to go. Or Dion Jordan. Whatever.

There was no elite QB and no elite WR. So oh well.

Everyone but ChiefsPlanet agrees the Chiefs made the right pick. These are the same experts that promised everyone Geno wasn't elite. Seems like they are smarter than SNR and Milkman. They get paid, there is a reason for it.

Falling in the draft means you can't be an elite player?


I thought you said Russell Wilson was elite?

You can't have it both ways dude. Those same experts said he wasn't elite. Those same gm's passed more than they did on Geno.

You can't have it bug ways Hootie
Posted via Mobile Device

[ChiefRocka]

Originally Posted by whoman69

The number one pick is supposed to be an impact player. It seems like we're just making a lateral move.

Our #1 will eliminate impacts on the QB and JC.
Great great pick. They didn't take the safe OT.

[Dave Lane]

Originally Posted by Peyton's Princess

we got the best QB prospect in this draft at #34

not bad

Stupid beyond belief

[Lightrise]

I'll play the game from similar perspective - personnel. I view these things like Deion Sanders and Kurt Warner do - looking for swagger - Jared Allen types, playmakers (Shannon Sharpe), winners (Warner sees something in EJ Manuel and a few months ago I read where Andy Reid focused on him too), fearless guys like Dale Carter. This is one reason I am relieved with the Fisher pick. That guy will be successful. When it comes to TE I admit to being totally spoiled from the Gonzalez experience and its more important these guys get open and catch the ball than block. I fix that weakness with HOF guards if possible. If there's one thing I've learned to hate as a Chiefs fan it is pressure coming up the middle. If you can't prevent that then you have to have a quick release QB and run the west coast offense.

So - given the veteran challenge at QB in our division Alex Smith was the right choice to try and win while we still have to cope with Manning and Rivers. Our division will reset soon...2 more years I figure.

It's too early to tell with Reid and Dorsey...but the Chiefs have to get a lot nastier. That is one reason I hated to lose Haley...the team needed his passion. It's just a shame ***** was so wrong for a coach like that. They fired the wrong guy who never got the coaches and QB he deserved the latitude to find. But now that the damage has been done...Reid and Dorsey are a logical fit to clean this up.

[DTLB58]

Well, it sure seems a lot of us were smarter than Pioli/Haley/Romeo so sure, Why not?

That's NOT sarcasm btw.

It's really obvious that Reid is building this offense a LOT different than the rest of the NFL. Mainly because of the QB.

[Mother****erJones]

Ladies and Gentlemen, our contestants today are John Dorsey and Andy Reid.

Are You Smarter Than A Fifth Grader? LET'S PLAY!

[SAUTO]

Both ways Hootie
Posted via Mobile Device