*****Trade analysis superthread 2013*****

[AndChiefs]

Originally Posted by Pestilence

Need to see the rest of your team before I can decide.

Team 1:

QB: Matt Ryan, Eli Manning
WR: Danny Amendola, Marques Colston, Michael Floyd, Chris Givens, Cecil Shorts
RB: Jamaal Charles, DeMarco Murray, Eddie Lacy, David Wilson
TE: Jason Witten, Rob Housler
K: Alex Henery
DEF: Patriots, Giants

Team 2:

QB: Aaron Rodgers
WR: Victor Cruz, Torrey Smith, Anquan Boldin, T.Y. Hilton, Kenbrell Thompkins
RB: Steven Jackson, Doug Martin, Montee Ball, Ben Tate, Shane Vereen
TE: Jared Cook, Rob Gronkowski
K: Caleb Sturgis, Rob Bironas
DEF: Cardinals

[Jewish Rabbi]

Originally Posted by AndChiefs

Team 1:

QB: Matt Ryan, Eli Manning
WR: Danny Amendola, Marques Colston, Michael Floyd, Chris Givens, Cecil Shorts
RB: Jamaal Charles, DeMarco Murray, Eddie Lacy, David Wilson
TE: Jason Witten, Rob Housler
K: Alex Henery
DEF: Patriots, Giants

Team 2:

QB: Aaron Rodgers
WR: Victor Cruz, Torrey Smith, Anquan Boldin, T.Y. Hilton, Kenbrell Thompkins
RB: Steven Jackson, Doug Martin, Montee Ball, Ben Tate, Shane Vereen
TE: Jared Cook, Rob Gronkowski
K: Caleb Sturgis, Rob Bironas
DEF: Cardinals

I don't understand why Team 1 would make that trade. Not really improving the roster.

[AndChiefs]

Originally Posted by Jewish Rabbi

I don't understand why Team 1 would make that trade. Not really improving the roster.

I've decided to turn down the offer. Seemed to be people falling on each side of the aisle but I agree with this statement.

I'm Team 1, btw.

[mrroandrro]

Team 2:

QB: Aaron Rodgers
WR: Victor Cruz, Torrey Smith, Anquan Boldin, T.Y. Hilton, Kenbrell Thompkins
RB: Steven Jackson, Doug Martin, Montee Ball, Ben Tate, Shane Vereen
TE: Jared Cook, Rob Gronkowski
K: Caleb Sturgis, Rob Bironas
DEF: Cardinals

You drafted 2 kickers because???

[AndChiefs]

Originally Posted by mrroandrro

You drafted 2 kickers because???

Well..since I'm the team with one kicker I wouldn't be able to tell you.

[mrroandrro]

Originally Posted by AndChiefs

Well..since I'm the team with one kicker I wouldn't be able to tell you.

Apologies, thought you drafted 2 teams

[Bewbies]

Standard league, I was offered Bowe for Reggie Wayne. Leaning toward taking it...

[AndChiefs]

Originally Posted by Bewbies

Standard league, I was offered Bowe for Reggie Wayne. Leaning toward taking it...

I think I'd take it as well. I know Wayne surged again last year but he's old and bound to regress. Smith doesn't have a whole lot of targets available.

[ChiefGator]

I have an embarrassment of riches at the RB position (Charles, Spiller, Bush, and Miller in a 1/2 ppr) and only Greg Olsen as TE.

Would you consider this a good trade:

Greg Olsen + Lamar Miller for Witten (+ Fasano)?

I already offered to someone else:

Greg Olsen + Lamar Miller for Gronkowski (+ some scrub), which I don't expect to happen in preseason. Maybe once Lamar proves some people wrong and if Olsen has a good start to the season.

I'm really set at QB, WR, and RB, but want to improve my TE. Or is the non-sexy Greg Olsen better than any of those offers?

(Oh, we only start 2 RB's with an open-flex position which will be occupied by my 2nd QB)

[AndChiefs]

Originally Posted by ChiefGator

I have an embarrassment of riches at the RB position (Charles, Spiller, Bush, and Miller in a 1/2 ppr) and only Greg Olsen as TE.

Would you consider this a good trade:

Greg Olsen + Lamar Miller for Witten (+ Fasano)?

I already offered to someone else:

Greg Olsen + Lamar Miller for Gronkowski (+ some scrub), which I don't expect to happen in preseason. Maybe once Lamar proves some people wrong and if Olsen has a good start to the season.

I'm really set at QB, WR, and RB, but want to improve my TE. Or is the non-sexy Greg Olsen better than any of those offers?

(Oh, we only start 2 RB's with an open-flex position which will be occupied by my 2nd QB)

I'd take that Witten deal in a heartbeat. Two RB's with a good backup in a PPR league should be plenty. You're looking at an extra 40-50 receptions from Witten over Olsen.

[Chiefshrink]

Originally Posted by AndChiefs

I'd take that Witten deal in a heartbeat. Two RB's with a good backup in a PPR league should be plenty. You're looking at an extra 40-50 receptions from Witten over Olsen.

AGREED. DO IT NOW !!!

Witten is Romo's BINKY at all times and rarely gets hurt. Hell he came back last year before he was actually ready and still produced. Tough as hell.

[Chiefshrink]

Originally Posted by Bewbies

Standard league, I was offered Bowe for Reggie Wayne. Leaning toward taking it...

Originally Posted by AndChiefs

I think I'd take it as well. I know Wayne surged again last year but he's old and bound to regress. Smith doesn't have a whole lot of targets available.

I get your thinking here BUT Wayne will still out produce Bowe IMO because Smith won't have an O-line to protect him because our interior O-line sucks and Bowe goes back to his ADD hands this year IMHO. Luck is still young and he will still rely on that great chemistry he has with Wayne and I see Luck being a top 5 fantasy QB this year !!

[Chiefshrink]

Originally Posted by ChiefGator

I have an embarrassment of riches at the RB position (Charles, Spiller, Bush, and Miller in a 1/2 ppr)

At the beginning of every season everyone's team seems very salty because it is on paper. Paper and reality are two different worlds. Not trying to be a Debbie Downer here with all due respect but.....

1. Our interior O-line better get better quickly IF Charles is to have a good to great year. Initially he will only be good out of the backfield and at the WR/Slot positions IMHO and then once opposing D's realize our interior O-line sucks they will start to game for Charles out of the backfield/slot positions and take that away as well.

2. Spiller - injury risk, inconsistent and he plays for the Bills who have QB drama going on which means teams will stack the box until their QB play gets better.

3. Bush - HIGH injury risk and plays behind an O-line that is just about as bad as our interior O-line which means teams will do the same to the Dolphins as they do to the Chiefs. See point 1.

4. Miller - see point 1 without the injury risk.

[The Franchise]

Olsen is going to be Newton's #2 target in the passing game. I'd stick with him and keep your awesome RB depth.

[ChiefGator]

Originally Posted by AndChiefs

I'd take that Witten deal in a heartbeat. Two RB's with a good backup in a PPR league should be plenty. You're looking at an extra 40-50 receptions from Witten over Olsen.

Originally Posted by Pestilence

Olsen is going to be Newton's #2 target in the passing game. I'd stick with him and keep your awesome RB depth.

Sounds like the internal battle in my head....

Any other votes?