Would you rather be 8-0 with Alex Smith or 3-5 with Geno?

[RINGLEADER]

Originally Posted by Discuss Thrower

Of course I'd be the only one to vote Geno so far. Whatever.

It comes down to this: does Alex have the capability to win a SB without an astronomically good defense and all the lucky breaks in the world? Probably not.

Does Geno? Maybe.

Who will be in the league as a starter seven years from now? Probably Geno.

Geno can't win in the regular season, what makes you think he'll do better in the post-season?

Truth is that two ticky-tack fouls that had nothing to do with Geno's skills (or lack thereof) led to half his wins this season. Ignore those and he's 2-6, which is probably a closer representation of his actual skills.