Manning or Orton?

[Frankie]

Originally Posted by Okie_Apparition

Indy needs to rebuild & I doubt the offense under Manning is the same as they'd have for Luck
that 28+ million for Peyton's salary could buy some nice toys

Unless their GM is Scott Pioli and their owner, Clark Hunt.

Originally Posted by Rexx

Why would you take Orton over Manning? Chiefs have the cap space if they decide they want to go for Manning. He has a few years left and would have no issue with them going that route. IMO, they would be legitimate Super Bowl contenders assuming Manning is injury free.

Because I don't believe Manning's neck is as healthy or durable as the Colts want you to believe.