Andrew Luck sacked 6 times today; that's 31 through 8 games. On pace for 62.

[oaklandhater]

Player Sk Year
David Carr (23) 76 2002
Randall Cunningham (23) 72 1986
David Carr (26) 68 2005
Jon Kitna (33) 63 2006


So he would take the top 5 spot you can see how the texans ruined Carr man 76 sacks in one year wow.

[Indian Chief]

Originally Posted by oaklandhater

Player Sk Year
David Carr (23) 76 2002
Randall Cunningham (23) 72 1986
David Carr (26) 68 2005
Jon Kitna (33) 63 2006


So he would take the top 5 spot you can see how the texans ruined Carr man 76 sacks in one year wow.

As soon as I saw the thread title, I thought about David Carr.

[oaklandhater]

Originally Posted by Indian Chief

As soon as I saw the thread title, I thought about David Carr.

if luck keeps getting sacked like this every season his name will be mentioned with Carr has wasted potential.

[keg in kc]

Originally Posted by oaklandhater

if luck keeps getting sacked like this every season his name will be mentioned with Carr has wasted potential.

Yeah no. Luck has already had a solid career under his belt, already considered one of the elite signal callers in the league. He's about as far from David Carr as you can get. He's actually about as far along now in games played as Carr had for his entire career.

[milkman]

Originally Posted by keg in kc

Yeah no. Luck has already had a solid career under his belt, already overrated one of the elite signal callers in the league. He's about as far from David Carr as you can get. He's actually about as far along now in games played as Carr had for his entire career.

FYP

[keg in kc]

Originally Posted by milkman

FYP

****ed up my post, maybe. He's not overrated at all in my opinion. He's Aaron Rodgers without the four years to develop on the sidelines. So we get to see all his growing pains from day one.

[milkman]

Originally Posted by keg in kc

****ed up my post, maybe. He's not overrated at all in my opinion. He's Aaron Rodgers without the four years to develop on the sidelines. So we get to see all his growing pains from day one.

He isn't elite, right now.

Saying that he is elite, today, is overrating him.

He can still grow into that elite status, but he ain't there yet

[milkman]

Originally Posted by Indian Chief

As soon as I saw the thread title, I thought about David Carr.

I have said this time and time again.

David Carr never learned to read a defense, locked on to his primary target, and held the ball far too long.

The Texans line wasn't good, but he was every bit as responsible for those sacks as those guys.

He took 44 sacks in his last season as a starter.
The following season, with Jordan Black as the only upgrade, that same line gave up 22 sacks.

Andrew Luck isn't nearly as bad at reads as Carr, but there is no question that he also holds the ball far too long, and bears as much responsibility for those sack numbers as his line.

If a QB is getting sacked 40 plus times, it isn't just the line's fault.