Football Alternate Reality Game 3: Starting From Scratch (ROSTERS only) - Page 3

Mile High Mania · 03:02 PM

Ok guys, I'll put a link to this in the main thread... maybe RM or someone can update the header to show this link.

I think there was interest in using a different thread to post full rosters and commentary, so that's what we can use this thread for ... no trade info or picks, just post your rosters as they are updated and any commentary that you care to provide.

Others are more than welcome to post their feedback (good, bad and ugly).

Have fun.

The MAIN DRAFTING THREAD IS --> http://www.chiefsplanet.com/BB/showthread.php?t=204588

**Rain Man** · 07-20-2009, 02:26 PM

When the rosters are complete, I think I'll do a "season beginning poll", and ask the voters to rank each unit on the teams. Probably a version for the 2009 season and a version of "looking both now and to the future". It'll only be for show since the real decisions will come at the end of the season, but it'll give us some objective feedback.

chiefscafan · 07-20-2009, 02:29 PM

I'm wrong? Doomy you are telling me your d is better?? Besides nt I beat you overall no way your o is better but my d is by far better than yours.

**The Franchise** · 07-20-2009, 02:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by chiefscafan

Los Angeles Purple Cobras:

Defense
DE John Henderson

OLB James Harrison
ILB Bay Lewis
ILB Bart Scott
OLB Terrel Suggs

RCB Brandon Flowers
LCB Dunta Robinson
FS Antrelle rolle
SS Brandon Merriweather

PR/KR josh cribbs

and latest addition DE Trevor Price

Quote:

Originally Posted by doomy3

The Chattanooga Choo-Choos:

Defense:

CB: Nnamdi Asonugha
CB: Leodis McKelvin (Also PR/KR)
CB: Chris Gamble
FS: Aquib Talib
SS: Bob Sanders
MLB: Stewart Bradley
OLB: A.J. Hawk
OLB: Ernie Sims
OLB/DE: Manny Lawson
DE: Trent Cole
DE: Derrick Harvey
DE: Andre Carter
DT: Adam Carriker
DT: Ty Warren
DT: Kelly Gregg

Dude....I'll go ahead and compare your defenses.

Defensive Line - The nod goes to Choo-Choos. Not only are his starters good....but he's got a ton of depth in pass rushers.

Linebackers - Honestly....I'll give the edge to the Cobras...only because he's got great LBs for a 3-4. But honestly dude.....you just grabbed the Ravens old LB corp...and added Harrison. Minus Suggs....you don't have too much youth. The Choo-Choos don't have a bunch of slackers either.

Defensive Backfield - Easily given to the Choo-Choos. Asomaugha (sp) and Gamble are two awesome starting CBs....and McKelvin is a great nickle (and kick/punt returner). Talib is a ballhawk at FS and Sanders is a punisher at SS. The Cobras have some great young safetys but your CBs are iffy. Flowers is good...but he has to prove it again and Robinson is good...but not great.

chiefscafan · 07-20-2009, 02:44 PM

Ok I figured this would happen when all is said and done my d will be better. But you can have your opinion mile who I think has unbias opinion said I like that D. You guys are putting way too much value on youth in this thing and are missing solid older players for the potential of youth. I have a complete team I have the best kr now in the game arguablly one of the best kickers in the league. Everyone questions me trading for cassel but what if he is great. By the end of this it's gonna be hard to find a weakness.

chiefscafan · 07-20-2009, 02:50 PM

Who on the d line besides Warren? Carricker? Young but what has he done, Carter?,

They all are better than pryce and henderson??

Heck I'm surprised u even gave me the LB core although u did take a pop shot at me again bout taking alot of ravens? Should I be blasted for this. I figure you also think it was a bad idea for the owner to take almost the whole Titan o line. It's a long way to go pest before you or doomy claim the championship.

**doomy3** · 07-20-2009, 02:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by chiefscafan

Who on the d line besides Warren? Carricker? Young but what has he done, Carter?,

They all are better than pryce and henderson??

Heck I'm surprised u even gave me the LB core although u did take a pop shot at me again bout taking alot of ravens? Should I be blasted for this. I figure you also think it was a bad idea for the owner to take almost the whole Titan o line. It's a long way to go pest before you or doomy claim the championship.

Dude, calm down. You posted your roster for feedback, and made a claim that you have the best defense. That's all fine, that's your opinion. No one is "blasting" anyone.

IMO, my defense is much better than yours at nearly every position. Luckily, the other members on CP will be voting on this, so yours and mine opinions really don't matter all that much.

**Old Dog** · 07-20-2009, 03:00 PM

My team won't look good to the voters, but many of them (if any bother to vote) will vote purely on names, and I don't have the big name guys, just solid players, and one of the younger teams assembled.

Mr. Arrowhead · 07-20-2009, 03:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mile High Mania

Arrowhead... I think you said you were unhappy with your team, but I think you're in good shape.

Great balance at QB with solid upside in Flacco and a proven Hasselbeck with 1-2 solid years left in him, and he now has TJ Housh... great weapon.

RB - very solid!

WR - you have two great weapons and Royal as a return man is double bonus.

The OL is a work in progress and you have some great components on the defense too. Very nice.

yea i guess im just not that big of a Flacco fan, but i do think i like the rest of my team.

**The Franchise** · 07-20-2009, 03:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by chiefscafan

Who on the d line besides Warren? Carricker? Young but what has he done, Carter?,

They all are better than pryce and henderson??

Heck I'm surprised u even gave me the LB core although u did take a pop shot at me again bout taking alot of ravens? Should I be blasted for this. I figure you also think it was a bad idea for the owner to take almost the whole Titan o line. It's a long way to go pest before you or doomy claim the championship.

Dude...I said that he had the best team based on potential. And yeah I did blast the guy who took the entire Titan's o-line.

chiefscafan · 07-20-2009, 03:15 PM

I think it's crazy doomy that you think your d is easily better than mine who is your pass rush? Lawson?? Carter?? Harvey?? And that's better than suggs Harrison pryce. I'm sorry man but you are dillusional.

Mile High Mania · 07-20-2009, 03:16 PM

CAT FIGHT!!!!

I hope nobody takes any offense to the commentary... I think the comments and feedback are great and I think a few of us will take shots at each other because we're pretty sure the other guy can take it.

So, if anyone thinks "Dammit - that ahole just blasted my team" when reading my comments, please know that I'm not saying you're a fool for the team you've built. I'm just trying to have some fun.

I'm hoping that everyone is taking this approach.

If I'm comparing teams, yes I will do my best to make the argument for my squad, but I'll acknowledge defeat when appropriate.

Regarding the youth comment... I'm loading up with youth because I pulled a Ditka and traded my rookie picks. So, that's the course I chose to take.

I think you should definitely plug in the older veterans when you can, hell I won't pass on a guy (TJ Housh, Kreutz as examples) if they're in their 30s.

But, overall... I'm looking for the foundation to be 2-3 year veterans for the most part.

Voting - I do think that many will look at names and say "Damn, that dude has X Player... by default he wins". I get it and it's similar to Pro-Bowl voting, so while I think my collection of phenoms in the making is superior, I'm certainly not expecting to win any fan voting.

**The Franchise** · 07-20-2009, 03:17 PM

You know what....I'm not comparing anyone's teams again until this thing is finished. People getting butthurt over the stupidest shit.

Mile High Mania · 07-20-2009, 03:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pestilence

You know what....I'm not comparing anyone's teams again until this thing is finished. People getting butthurt over the stupidest shit.

Oh stop it... I think this is all about nothing. It's more sports debate. I think we just need to make sure we hold back on the "Man, are you kidding? Your team sucks..." and just focus on the "No, that team is better and here is why.."

We'll all be fine. C'mon, it's a bunch of dudes cyber-kicking each other in the groin about football...

And, that being said... my only real weak link right now is QB (thanks to injury) and OL (injury at LT and lack of bodies right now)... everywhere else (RB/WR/LB/DB)... I'm set and you guys are envious. I know.

**doomy3** · 07-20-2009, 03:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by chiefscafan

I think it's crazy doomy that you think your d is easily better than mine who is your pass rush? Lawson?? Carter?? Harvey?? And that's better than suggs Harrison pryce. I'm sorry man but you are dillusional.

Just because you don't know who they are doesn't mean they aren't good.

Trent Cole, Andre Carter and Derrick Harvey can all rush the passer. Andre Carter could be VERY good this year now that he is playing on the same side as Albert Haynesworth and will be rushing like crazy. Ty Warren and Adam Carriker are athletic DTs who can get after the QB from the inside and Kelly Gregg is a big space eating run-stuffer. Plus, considering I have one of the best secondaries anyone could put together, that will help the pass rush since receivers won't be getting open easily. Any other questions?

**Kyle DeLexus** · 07-20-2009, 03:32 PM

Offense

QB Tom Brady
RB Frank Gore
RB Derrick Ward
WR Braylon Edwards
WR Kevin Walter
WR Devin Hester
LT Michael Roos
LG Todd Herremans
C
RG Jake Scott
RT David Stewart

Defense

DE Cullen Jenkins
NT Vince Wilfork
DE Corey Williams
OLB Osi Umenyiora
ILB James Farrior
ILB Barrett Ruud
OLB Calvin Pace
CB Terence Newman
CB Ellis Hobbs
FS Antoine Bethea
SS

07-19-2009, 02:56 PM
Mile High Mania #triggering Join Date: Aug 2000 Location: Tejas Casino cash: $3417229	Alternate Reality Game 3: Starting From Scratch (ROSTERS only) Ok guys, I'll put a link to this in the main thread... maybe RM or someone can update the header to show this link. I think there was interest in using a different thread to post full rosters and commentary, so that's what we can use this thread for ... no trade info or picks, just post your rosters as they are updated and any commentary that you care to provide. Others are more than welcome to post their feedback (good, bad and ugly). Have fun. The MAIN DRAFTING THREAD IS --> http://www.chiefsplanet.com/BB/showthread.php?t=204588 Last edited by Mile High Mania; 07-19-2009 at 03:02 PM..
Posts: 30,348

07-20-2009, 02:26 PM	#31
Rain Man NFL's #1 Ermines Fan Join Date: Jul 2001 Location: My house Casino cash: $2958491 VARSITY	When the rosters are complete, I think I'll do a "season beginning poll", and ask the voters to rank each unit on the teams. Probably a version for the 2009 season and a version of "looking both now and to the future". It'll only be for show since the real decisions will come at the end of the season, but it'll give us some objective feedback. __________________ I'm putting random letters here as a celebration of free speech: xigrakgrah misorojeq rkemeseit.
Posts: 141,713

07-20-2009, 02:29 PM	#32
chiefscafan Veteran Join Date: Nov 2001 Location: manhattan beach, CA Casino cash: $9688215	I'm wrong? Doomy you are telling me your d is better?? Besides nt I beat you overall no way your o is better but my d is by far better than yours.
Posts: 4,425

07-20-2009, 02:44 PM	#34
chiefscafan Veteran Join Date: Nov 2001 Location: manhattan beach, CA Casino cash: $9688215	Ok I figured this would happen when all is said and done my d will be better. But you can have your opinion mile who I think has unbias opinion said I like that D. You guys are putting way too much value on youth in this thing and are missing solid older players for the potential of youth. I have a complete team I have the best kr now in the game arguablly one of the best kickers in the league. Everyone questions me trading for cassel but what if he is great. By the end of this it's gonna be hard to find a weakness.
Posts: 4,425

07-20-2009, 02:50 PM	#35
chiefscafan Veteran Join Date: Nov 2001 Location: manhattan beach, CA Casino cash: $9688215	Who on the d line besides Warren? Carricker? Young but what has he done, Carter?, They all are better than pryce and henderson?? Heck I'm surprised u even gave me the LB core although u did take a pop shot at me again bout taking alot of ravens? Should I be blasted for this. I figure you also think it was a bad idea for the owner to take almost the whole Titan o line. It's a long way to go pest before you or doomy claim the championship.
Posts: 4,425

07-20-2009, 03:00 PM	#37
Old Dog Supporter Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: North Central Kansas Casino cash: $4535131	My team won't look good to the voters, but many of them (if any bother to vote) will vote purely on names, and I don't have the big name guys, just solid players, and one of the younger teams assembled.
Posts: 10,676

07-20-2009, 03:15 PM	#40
chiefscafan Veteran Join Date: Nov 2001 Location: manhattan beach, CA Casino cash: $9688215	I think it's crazy doomy that you think your d is easily better than mine who is your pass rush? Lawson?? Carter?? Harvey?? And that's better than suggs Harrison pryce. I'm sorry man but you are dillusional.
Posts: 4,425

07-20-2009, 03:16 PM	#41
Mile High Mania #triggering Join Date: Aug 2000 Location: Tejas Casino cash: $3417229	CAT FIGHT!!!! I hope nobody takes any offense to the commentary... I think the comments and feedback are great and I think a few of us will take shots at each other because we're pretty sure the other guy can take it. So, if anyone thinks "Dammit - that ahole just blasted my team" when reading my comments, please know that I'm not saying you're a fool for the team you've built. I'm just trying to have some fun. I'm hoping that everyone is taking this approach. If I'm comparing teams, yes I will do my best to make the argument for my squad, but I'll acknowledge defeat when appropriate. Regarding the youth comment... I'm loading up with youth because I pulled a Ditka and traded my rookie picks. So, that's the course I chose to take. I think you should definitely plug in the older veterans when you can, hell I won't pass on a guy (TJ Housh, Kreutz as examples) if they're in their 30s. But, overall... I'm looking for the foundation to be 2-3 year veterans for the most part. Voting - I do think that many will look at names and say "Damn, that dude has X Player... by default he wins". I get it and it's similar to Pro-Bowl voting, so while I think my collection of phenoms in the making is superior, I'm certainly not expecting to win any fan voting. __________________
Posts: 30,348

07-20-2009, 03:17 PM	#42
The Franchise Most Valuable Villain Join Date: Dec 2006 Casino cash: $2745047	You know what....I'm not comparing anyone's teams again until this thing is finished. People getting butthurt over the stupidest shit.
Posts: 92,303

07-20-2009, 03:32 PM	#45
Kyle DeLexus Opie and Anthony XM 105 Join Date: Nov 2008 Casino cash: $10002400	Offense QB Tom Brady RB Frank Gore RB Derrick Ward WR Braylon Edwards WR Kevin Walter WR Devin Hester LT Michael Roos LG Todd Herremans C RG Jake Scott RT David Stewart Defense DE Cullen Jenkins NT Vince Wilfork DE Corey Williams OLB Osi Umenyiora ILB James Farrior ILB Barrett Ruud OLB Calvin Pace CB Terence Newman CB Ellis Hobbs FS Antoine Bethea SS
Posts: 7,910