What if Charles really did get more carries? Wicket stat.

[-King-]

OnTheWarpath....the next Dane in terms of hypocritical posts?

Originally Posted by OnTheWarpath58

It's subjective.

Just like the "drops" stat.

Originally Posted by OnTheWarpath58

Which is why the drop stat is ****ing reeruned.

Originally Posted by OnTheWarpath58

Funny how you ignore the stat I posted for 2008.

And ignore BossChief's post.

And ignore that drops are a subjective stat. What's considered a drop in Kc may not be considered a drop in Houston or New Orleans.

Which is why it's ****ing reeruned to get worked up over.

Originally Posted by OnTheWarpath58

Again, drops are a subjective stat.

If the ball is thrown well behind Bowe, and he has to attempt a circus catch and fails, is that a drop?

It shouldn't be.

Are the decision makers checking replays to see if the defender got a piece of the ball, or are they going on what they see at full speed?

I can think of 2 or 3 instances last year where people here got pissy over a supposed drop and the replay showed the defender getting a hand on the ball.

....I can go on for about 100 posts...

[OnTheWarpath15]

Originally Posted by -King-

Wait....so now you're saying that the drop stat isn't subjective?

Originally Posted by -King-

OnTheWarpath....the next Dane in terms of hypocritical posts?









....I can go on for about 100 posts...

Sure, the stat is subjective to you or I.

STATS has an established, uniform criteria set to determine what is and what isn't a drop.

I'm going to trust the experts over the fans on this one.

[-King-]

Originally Posted by OnTheWarpath58

Sure, the stat is subjective to you or I.

STATS has an established, uniform criteria set to determine what is and what isn't a drop.

I'm going to trust the experts over the fans on this one.

Bowe had 2 straight drops in Houston. The TD pass and the quick slant. He also had a drop at Indy. He had that drop on 3rd down in Oakland. Thats 4 drops. You're saying that he only had 1 other drop in his other 500 plays?

[OnTheWarpath15]

Originally Posted by -King-

Bowe had 2 straight drops in Houston. The TD pass and the quick slant. He also had a drop at Indy. He had that drop on 3rd down in Oakland. Thats 4 drops. You're saying that he only had 1 other drop in his other 500 plays?

Hard to take you seriously when you can't get your facts straight.

He had the two straight drops in Indy, not Houston.

I don't recall a drop in Houston. Feel free to show evidence to the contrary.

The drop in Oakland. That's three.

[-King-]

Originally Posted by OnTheWarpath58

Hard to take you seriously when you can't get your facts straight.

He had the two straight drops in Indy, not Houston.

I don't recall a drop in Houston. Feel free to show evidence to the contrary.

The drop in Oakland. That's three.

Ok, got my teams mixed up. Still, so he has 3 drops in just those games. In the other games he has only 2?


You've said it yourself that the drop stat is a bullshit stat. How can you say that and then say that you trust it?

[OnTheWarpath15]

Originally Posted by -King-

Ok, got my teams mixed up. Still, so he has 3 drops in just those games. In the other games he has only 2?


You've said it yourself that the drop stat is a bullshit stat. How can you say that and then say that you trust it?

I said it was reeruned.

And I still feel that way. Not because I think the data is inaccurate, but that people here continue to bitch about what is and what isn't a drop.

[SAUTO]

Originally Posted by OnTheWarpath58

I said it was reeruned.

And I still feel that way. Not because I think the data is inaccurate, but that people here continue to bitch about what is and what isn't a drop.

thats because there is NO set criteria.


and i believe that Bowe has done a much better job of acutually catching the ball this year.