Just how valuable is a QB?

[Direckshun]

Originally Posted by Direckshun

A more representative question of the issue would be...

All things being equal, would you rather take a 2% chance on the next Aaron Rodgers who's probably just a decent starter, or a 50% chance on an All Pro caliber tackle, who's probably just going to be a very good tackle.

Keep in mind, you do have picks in the future where you can take a shot at future Aaron Rodgers who might have a higher than 2% chance of hitting.

Becomes a bit cloudier, doesn't it.

Also, add into it that your family JUST moved into Kansas City, is getting settled, and your job is likely on the line with the QB you draft, which also precludes you from taking any other high-ranking QB prospects in the next two years, even if their percentage of Rodgering would be higher.

We get lifetime tenures as fans. It is not that easy for coaches, who have to calculate risk into everything they do.