Just how valuable is a QB?

[Direckshun]

Originally Posted by Pestilence

So now Geno Smith has a 2% chance of being the next Aaron Rodgers but Joeckel has a 50% chance of being an All Pro LT?

All Pro caliber, at least, yes.

Originally Posted by Pestilence

You also have future picks to spend on that 50% shot at an All Pro LT. You know....the one from the same team and is a better OT overall.

You could.

But the debate isn't about the LT, really. It's about do you want to hamstring your chances at drafting a franchise QB in the next two years by spending 1.1 on a 2% chance of an All Pro QB? A guy with some serious bust potential, at that?

I don't agree with the decision Reid is making, but to claim it's incomprehensible is wrong.