HOF & 3 Coaches

[Amnorix]

Originally Posted by Mile High Mania

You can use that argument though for so many players and people do to either state the case as to why someone should be in or out of the HOF.

Yes - Rod had Elway for the majority of his years with Sharpe, Ed and Davis for several of them. But, Smith was on some good teams and while Brunell is not Elway, he was very productive in that system. Smith also had a solid RB (Taylor) supporting him and there was McCardell playing #2...

It's not like Jimmy Smith was playing with Peter Tom Willis at QB and Brandon Jackson at RB. They're very similar in production while playing on good offenses.

errr...Broncos offense was the best in the NFL some of those years. Heck, it won two SBs for you guys. Don't think Jax ever had that.

But yeah, it's so close it hardly matters. He's not the ARchie Manning of WRs or anything.

Again, both in or both out, is really the only "fair" result, IMHO. I'm thinking "out", myself, but as noted above I'm a very tough grader.