Geno Smith vs Alex Smith - It's on.

[Hammock Parties]

It's on now. Geno Smith is probably going to be starting for the Jets this season.

Alex Smith will be the Chiefs QB for the forseeable future. If he's a success, we'll probably get five good years out of him.

So who's gonna win more NFL games over that time period?

Put your ten pounders on the table and make a vote

Alex: 11 wins
Geno: 8 wins

[Sweet Daddy Hate]

Originally Posted by PGM

We won 2 games last year and have a badass defense. Couldn't take care of the ball, now are doing like I said all offseason what turns losing teams into winners. The top like 8 teams in the NFC in TO differential had winning records last year and like 5 of 6 in the AFC. I'm enjoying the **** out if it.

I enjoy it out in the real world, but CP is for critical thinking, pissing and moaning.

Is what it is.

[Hammock Parties]

The Jets and Chiefs run different style offenses, too.

Geno might be playing even better, with fewer turnovers, under Andy Reid.

Also, our OL would be better, because we wouldn't have Eric ****ing Fisher.

[BossChief]

We both run WCO

Marty Morningwig used to be Andys OC

[O.city]

Geno has thrown it downfield more and better, but he's struggled with placement in the short and intermediate routes iirc, which is where his picks have come from.

Which is curious as that's actually the opposite of what he was in college

[beach tribe]

Originally Posted by BigCatDaddy

Better weapons and offensive system in KC. Avery, Bowe, and JC blow shit up with Geno stretching the field. Dude goes for the jugular and doesn't patty cake it around like Alice.

Dude has hit defenders right between numbers on damn near all of his picks. That has nothing to do with the talent around him. Hes a rookie and hes gonna make mistakes...and he has made plenty of them. Its silly to think he would be blowing out anyone at this point. As a matter of fact there is more actual proof that would indicate there is a better chance that he would have cost the team a game with a costly turnover. He has played horribly under pressure so far, and our O-line has been the weak link up to this point.
Geno was the 1st rookie QB to throw 3 4th qtr picks since 91 in week two. There is no way we are 3-0 if he does that in any of our games.

[BigCatDaddy]

Originally Posted by beach tribe

Dude has hit defenders right between numbers on damn near all of his picks. That has nothing to do with the talent around him. Hes a rookie and hes gonna make mistakes...and he has made plenty of them. Its silly to think he would be blowing out anyone at this point. As a matter of fact there is more actual proof that would indicate there is a better chance that he would have cost the team a game with a costly turnover. He has played horribly under pressure so far, and our O-line has been the weak link up to this point.
Geno was the 1st rookie QB to throw 3 4th qtr picks since 91 in week two. There is no way we are 3-0 if he does that in any of our games.

Those are coachable. I think Andy would have had him more prepared than Rex/Marty so he would have made fewer mistakes. I'll say I'd be much more apt to buy a ticket to see Geno than Alice anyday. Geno just makes throws Alice would never dream of trying. In time I think he will be a top 10 guy.

[beach tribe]

Originally Posted by Pam Oliver's Forehead

The Jets and Chiefs run different style offenses, too.

Geno might be playing even better, with fewer turnovers, under Andy Reid.

Also, our OL would be better, because we wouldn't have Eric ****ing Fisher.

And he MIGHT and more than likely WOULD be, understandably, making rookie mistakes and costing the team.

[Sweet Daddy Hate]

You can't coach Unleashing The Dragon. You either have it or you don't.

[Sweet Daddy Hate]

Originally Posted by beach tribe

And he MIGHT and more than likely WOULD be, understandably, making rookie mistakes and costing the team.

If's and buts and candy and nuts and...


























Unleash that Mother****ing Dragon!

[OnTheWarpath15]

Originally Posted by beach tribe

And he MIGHT and more than likely WOULD be, understandably, making rookie mistakes and costing the team.

So let me get this straight:

He'd be making rookie mistakes in KC that would cost the team.

Meanwhile, he's making rookie mistakes now while surrounded by hot garbage on offense and a lessor defense than ours - yet he's not costing the team.

They're 2-1.

They've already won half as many games as most people expected them to.

I swear, y'all really should think things through before you post them.

[Sweet Daddy Hate]

Originally Posted by OnTheWarpath58

So let me get this straight:

He'd be making rookie mistakes in KC that would cost the team.

Meanwhile, he's making rookie mistakes now while surrounded by hot garbage on offense and a lessor defense than ours - yet he's not costing the team.

They're 2-1.

They've already won half as many games as most people expected them to.

I swear, y'all really should think things through before you post them.

And considering our awesome defense, this obsession with not turning the ball over seems overblown in light of having a young, chocolate peen that can....



wait for it....


















Unleash THAT MOTHER****ING DRAGON! W00T!

[beach tribe]

Originally Posted by BigCatDaddy

Those are coachable. I think Andy would have had him more prepared than Rex/Marty so he would have made fewer mistakes. I'll say I'd be much more apt to buy a ticket to see Geno than Alice anyday. Geno just makes throws Alice would never dream of trying. In time I think he will be a top 10 guy.

You may very well turn out to be right. He can make every throw, and has all the talent in the world, but all of the actual evidence, his rating, int pace (4 more than the record), and worst of all red zone INTs lean in the opposite direction.

Again, the guy is a rookie. He is gonna make mistakes. He will have every opportunity to prove the naysayers wrong, and has the talent to do so, but everything that has actually happened, and not (Well I think under Reid he would...) doesnt support the argument that he would be winning games here. Much less blowing people out.

my quotation button is broke BTW.

[OnTheWarpath15]

Originally Posted by beach tribe

You may very well turn out to be right. He can make every throw, and has all the talent in the world, but all of the actual evidence, his rating, int pace (4 more than the record), and worst of all red zone INTs lean in the opposite direction.

Again, the guy is a rookie. He is gonna make mistakes. He will have every opportunity to prove the naysayers wrong, and has the talent to do so, but everything that has actually happened, and not (Well I think under Reid he would...) doesnt support the argument that he would be winning games here. Much less blowing people out.

my quotation button is broke BTW.

Again?



He's winning games in NY with no talent around him, but he'd suck if he were here?

[beach tribe]

Originally Posted by OnTheWarpath58

So let me get this straight:

He'd be making rookie mistakes in KC that would cost the team.

Meanwhile, he's making rookie mistakes now while surrounded by hot garbage on offense and a lessor defense than ours - yet he's not costing the team.

They're 2-1.

They've already won half as many games as most people expected them to.

I swear, y'all really should think things through before you post them.

Dude, he threw 3 4th quarter picks. You dont think that hurts the team??
What world are you living in?...fkn delusional.

He also threw picks that hurt the team VS Tampa but got the W because of a penalty.

And BTW Santonio Holmes is better than Avery, who has been our top weapon. Their line has played better, and their D is FAR from hot garbage

[Sweet Daddy Hate]

Originally Posted by OnTheWarpath58

Again?



He's winning games in NY with no talent around him, but he'd suck if he were here?

Mind numbling, it is.