Geno Smith vs Alex Smith - It's on.

[Hammock Parties]

It's on now. Geno Smith is probably going to be starting for the Jets this season.

Alex Smith will be the Chiefs QB for the forseeable future. If he's a success, we'll probably get five good years out of him.

So who's gonna win more NFL games over that time period?

Put your ten pounders on the table and make a vote

Alex: 11 wins
Geno: 8 wins

[Sweet Daddy Hate]

You detractors are just straight-up idiots. You don't get it, though it's been explained to you 100 times, and you probably never will. Some of you really believe that changing a regime somehow wipes the history-slate clean, though that proven history of FAIL is tied to one common denominator, a denominator which continues to this day.

And then there are you San Francisco shit-for-brains, who feel that we should be "lucky" to repeat our same old mistake with your latest cast-off.

YOU folks can truly go **** yourselves.

And finally, there's Lil' Dumbass Chiefy True Fan who only cares about winning enough to be a non-joke in the league(as well as a non-factor for a Championship, though he'll nevar acknowledge it because hope rides high(!), and "by golly, we'll get it RIGHT THIS TIME!).

Bottom Line:

Axl will NOT break this longstanding chain of events. It's not in his DNA. You can give him every single Chief in history that you would love to have on this team, in the PRIME of their playing years, and it's not going down.

You can build that fool a super-line and clone Jerry Rice:

NOT happening.

I'll enjoy not completely sucking until we have an actual future in place at the position, and THANK GOD we hired Dorsey who's not going to **** around with this shit forever during his tenure here. That is a man who will eventually, if necessary, confiscate Reid's mixed plate if shit goes stagnant at the Quarterback position in the name of an unwarranted man-crush.

[mattschiefs]

Originally Posted by BigCatDaddy

The ability to move the football is overrated/ Mattschiefs

We did that in 03 scored a TON of points

What happened in the playoffs?

[mattschiefs]

Originally Posted by Sweet Daddy Hate

You detractors are just straight-up idiots. You don't get it, though it's been explained to you 100 times, and you probably never will. Some of you really believe that changing a regime somehow wipes the history-slate clean, though that proven history of FAIL is tied to one common denominator, a denominator which continues to this day.

And then there are you San Francisco shit-for-brains, who feel that we should be "lucky" to repeat our same old mistake with your latest cast-off.

YOU folks can truly go **** yourselves.

And finally, there's Lil' Dumbass Chiefy True Fan who only cares about winning enough to be a non-joke in the league(as well as a non-factor for a Championship, though he'll nevar acknowledge it because hope rides high(!), and "by golly, we'll get it RIGHT THIS TIME!).

Bottom Line:

Axl will NOT break this longstanding chain of events. It's not in his DNA. You can give him every single Chief in history that you would love to have on this team, in the PRIME of their playing years, and it's not going down.

You can build that fool a super-line and clone Jerry Rice:

NOT happening.

I'll enjoy not completely sucking until we have an actual future in place at the position, and THANK GOD we hired Dorsey who's not going to **** around with this shit forever during his tenure here. That is a man who will eventually, if necessary, confiscate Reid's mixed plate if shit goes stagnant at the Quarterback position in the name of an unwarranted man-crush.

BOO Hoo the team didn't do what I want and people don't agree with me so now all I can do is throw out insults Because I have no facts to back up my opinion

99 browns drafted Tim couch Rams had a guy who was once bagging groceries It was the Browns that had the right choice.

Houston Texans fans are mad they got rid of David Carr and brought in Matt Schaub who although he's having bad year this year has been pretty good for them over all

The Cards Hated that same guy that was with the rams in 99 that took them to the superbowl

We all hated Trent Green Love Brodie Croyle

The Saints fans Hate Drew Brees

Cowboys fans hate tony Romo (well actually some do)

Yep the ONLY way to get a qb is through the draft

[Sweet Daddy Hate]

Originally Posted by mattschiefs

BOO Hoo the team didn't do what I want and people don't agree with me so now all I can do is throw out insults Because I have no facts to back up my opinion

99 browns drafted Tim couch Rams had a guy who was once bagging groceries It was the Browns that had the right choice.

Houston Texans fans are mad they got rid of David Carr and brought in Matt Schaub who although he's having bad year this year has been pretty good for them over all

The Cards Hated that same guy that was with the rams in 99 that took them to the superbowl

We all hated Trent Green Love Brodie Croyle

The Saints fans Hate Drew Brees

Cowboys fans hate tony Romo (well actually some do)

Yep the ONLY way to get a qb is through the draft

People, present chart and educate the youngling. I'm catching up on BB.

[BigCatDaddy]

Originally Posted by mattschiefs

We did that in 03 scored a TON of points

What happened in the playoffs?

What happened in the next Colts game when we didn't get a first down for the entire first half?

[mattschiefs]

Originally Posted by Sweet Daddy Hate

People, present chart and educate the youngling. I'm catching up on BB.

Don't have and answer for any of those QBs do we

[mattschiefs]

Originally Posted by BigCatDaddy

What happened in the next Colts game when we didn't get a first down for the entire first half?

Same thing that happened in 03 when we scored a ton of points we lost

But yes lets ignore that 03 and only look at 06 Way to go

[Pasta Little Brioni]

Great another mult

[Sweet Daddy Hate]

Originally Posted by PGM

Great another mult

Time for a MASS-flush.

[ShowtimeSBMVP]

Originally Posted by BigCatDaddy

How do you know?

How do you know Alex wont?

[NinerDoug]

Originally Posted by Sweet Daddy Hate

And then there are you San Francisco shit-for-brains, who feel that we should be "lucky" to repeat our same old mistake with your latest cast-off.

YOU folks can truly go **** yourselves.

Wow, what an ingrate. Next time we'll just keep our old quarterback, or give him to the Raiders.

[BigCatDaddy]

Originally Posted by ChiefsandO'sfan

How do you know Alex wont?

I don't. I mean Dilfer won one

[mattschiefs]

Originally Posted by BigCatDaddy

I don't. I mean Dilfer won one

And with that I rest my case

You don't have to have a high powered offense to win the superbowl even today. If you have the right mix of offense and defense you can win it. That's what they are trying to build. The offense has shown some flashes. They have looked horrible at others. Smith has made some mistakes but they haven't cost us a game. THe constant bashing of Alex Smith is not called for. END OF STORY

[Sandy Vagina]

Originally Posted by mattschiefs

And that I rest my case

You don't have to have a high powered offense to win the superbowl even today. If you have the right mix of offense and defense you can win it. That's what they are trying to build. The offense has shown some flashes. They have looked horrible at others. Smith has made some mistakes but they haven't cost us a game. THe constant bashing of Alex Smith is not called for. END OF STORY

plus, Alex's play and production is easily better than Dilfer's SB best.

[Mosbonian]

Originally Posted by Sweet Daddy Hate

You detractors are just straight-up idiots. You don't get it, though it's been explained to you 100 times, and you probably never will. Some of you really believe that changing a regime somehow wipes the history-slate clean, though that proven history of FAIL is tied to one common denominator, a denominator which continues to this day.

And then there are you San Francisco shit-for-brains, who feel that we should be "lucky" to repeat our same old mistake with your latest cast-off.

YOU folks can truly go **** yourselves.

And finally, there's Lil' Dumbass Chiefy True Fan who only cares about winning enough to be a non-joke in the league(as well as a non-factor for a Championship, though he'll nevar acknowledge it because hope rides high(!), and "by golly, we'll get it RIGHT THIS TIME!).

Bottom Line:

Axl will NOT break this longstanding chain of events. It's not in his DNA. You can give him every single Chief in history that you would love to have on this team, in the PRIME of their playing years, and it's not going down.

You can build that fool a super-line and clone Jerry Rice:

NOT happening.

I'll enjoy not completely sucking until we have an actual future in place at the position, and THANK GOD we hired Dorsey who's not going to **** around with this shit forever during his tenure here. That is a man who will eventually, if necessary, confiscate Reid's mixed plate if shit goes stagnant at the Quarterback position in the name of an unwarranted man-crush.

So.....here is the rub for me in all the arguments Geno/No Geno...

First...I never thought he was the pick at 1.1 and I would be interested in knowing how many really feel he would have been the right pick at that spot. If you are arguing that we should have kept our 2nd Round pick and taken a flier on him there I can understand that. But then my next question would have been had we taken him, how many of the impatient fans would be screaming for the Draft Packs head had Geno failed? I'm not convinced some of you would have been as patient with his "growing pains" as you are saying now.

I still believe it's too early to call G Smith a boom or bust....5 games really isn't enough to judge him by, anymore than the games Matt Cassel won at NE made him a quality QB.

I say you wait until the season is over with....that way if suddenly the Jets go on a 9 game losing streak and Geno's lack of experience is one of the reasons you aren't busy trying to rationalize. And...for those who are detractors, if he matures into the QB that his supporters believe he is/can be then you won't be trying to rationalize either.