Does Alex Smith deserve a extension after this season?

[Mosbonian]

Originally Posted by ComoLaz

I'm not a Alex Smith homer or basher.

He's not elite but he's done a pretty good job for us this year. I don't think our offensive talent around him is all that great.

Jamaal Charles is great, the rest is pretty average.


Alex Smith is just trying to win, whatever it takes. Even if it takes not throwing the ball much.

He is doing for us this year what we need him to do.....play effective no-TO football that makes sure we are in the game.

I don't care if he is/isn't a great QB.....I just want him to be a good and effective leader.

I think Charles is great, but without a good QB you go nowhere. All you have to do to see a comparison is Barry Sander's career.