Overdrafted/Underdrafted

[kccrow]

Originally Posted by O.city

You guys act as if NFL guards are the boogey man compared to NCAA level guards.

Come on man. There is a night and day difference. This is the type of comment that I expect from someone silly enough to say that a college team can compete against the Jaguars or something. NFL guards are far better than collegiate guards and you know it. Functional playing strength of a veteran guard is far greater than that of a college guard, and there is no question about it.

Is there a better than average chance Donald will become a good NFL player? I think so, I think his physical abilities are difficult to block in my experience. As a bigger player, it is difficult to move as fast as Donald at the snap which makes it more difficult to gain the leverage necessary to move him. However, NFL guards will get leverage and the results will not be good when they do.

Like I said, Donald will have to be put in the right scheme where he can use his athleticism to win the point of attack and disrupt the backfield. He's going to be able to do that as an under tackle in a 4-3 where he's playing the 3-technique primarily against slower players. That is the whole key because he will not be able to overcome the strength of NFL guards, it just is not going to happen. He has to beat them athletically, and that he is more than capable of.

He isn't going to line up on tackles and beat them in a 3-4 in my opinion. They are too in tune with smaller, faster, lineman and more ideally equipped to shut them down, so this dream some are having of him lining up as a defensive end in an odd front is laughable to me. Put him where he belongs, and there is a solid chance he's successful.