Was this the end of the Geno Smith era for New York Jets?

[KCrockaholic]

Originally Posted by King_Chief_Fan

You have to laugh at the chuckle heads who thought the Geno Smiff would be KC's answer at QB....they couldn't look more ignorant

Watched every pass attempt in his career at WV multiple times. I'm fine with the stance I came away with, and stick by it.

[Bufkin]

Originally Posted by KCrockaholic

Watched every pass attempt in his career at WV multiple times. I'm fine with the stance I came away with, and stick by it.

Or maybe you just suck at QB evaluation?

[KCrockaholic]

Originally Posted by Bufkin

Or maybe you just suck at QB evaluation?

Not quite. But I have no reason to be ashamed by my conclusions considering the work I put in, along with many other NFL scouts who also thought Geno was a first round QB.

I guess I could've just watched the K State game and drew an entire conclusion of Geno Smith based off that one game like many other people. Or just went with whatever was being said by the media at the time and form my opinions through them. That'd be too easy though.

[Chief Roundup]

Originally Posted by KCrockaholic

Not quite. But I have no reason to be ashamed by my conclusions considering the work I put in, along with many other NFL scouts who also thought Geno was a first round QB.

I guess I could've just watched the K State game and drew an entire conclusion of Geno Smith based off that one game like many other people. Or just went with whatever was being said by the media at the time and form my opinions through them. That'd be too easy though.

Well you and those scouts were wrong about Geno. It is evident that GMs across the league didn't agree with those scouts either. With the issues he showed there was no way he was worthy of the a first round pick. I didn't think he would get drafted until the 3rd round because of his issues.

[KCrockaholic]

Originally Posted by Chief Roundup

Well you and those scouts were wrong about Geno. It is evident that GMs across the league didn't agree with those scouts either. With the issues he showed there was no way he was worthy of the a first round pick. I didn't think he would get drafted until the 3rd round because of his issues.

The GM's had something I and the pro scouts didn't necessarily get to see. Multiple meetings and evaluations of his head wasn't something I had access to. I just had what was put on the field.