Alex Smith's 2nd year looks alot like Trent Green's 2nd yr w/Chiefs

[Easy 6]

Originally Posted by 'Hamas' Jenkins

Could Alex Smith put up the numbers that Flacco and Stafford have? No.

Could they do what Smith does? Absolutely. Chase Daniel just did what Alex Smith does on half a week's practice in his second career start.

Again, Alex Smith looks average because he takes no risks, so you don't have bad plays/decisions to point out, and since few of us have All-22, you can't see the numerous throws he leaves all over the field.

Ultimately, a QB that forces a ball in a tight spot on 3rd and goal twice and gets a touchdown and a pick out of it has made better plays than the guy who chucks it into the stands twice, but the second guy "protects the ball," so he's considered the better player. It's bullshit. Second grade math, actually.

7/2=3.5
6/2=3.

But both of those guys are statues, they'd barely be able to get off all of those long chucks behind this mess... and again, this isnt intended to absolve smith, just to point out that the line really is that bad.

75% of the time their back foot would just be hitting the 5th step before a defender came crashing down on them as they tried to sling it deep.

[rabblerouser]

Originally Posted by Easy 6

But both of those guys are statues, they'd barely be able to get off all of those long chucks behind this mess... and again, this isnt intended to absolve smith, just to point out that the line really is that bad.

75% of the time their back foot would just be hitting the 5th step before a defender came crashing down on them as they tried to sling it deep.

This sounds most plausible.

You win at the internet for today!!

[Easy 6]

Originally Posted by rabblerouser

This sounds most plausible.

You win at the internet for today!!

Dont take it as a Smith defense, whatever you do, because that guy ruined me on him in three games like I've truly never experienced before.

Its just that either one of those other guys would get creamed atleast twice as much as Smith when attempting a 5-7 step drop.

[rabblerouser]

Originally Posted by Easy 6

Dont take it as a Smith defense, whatever you do, because that guy ruined me on him in three games like I've truly never experienced before.

Its just that either one of those other guys would get creamed atleast twice as much as Smith when attempting a 5-7 step drop.

I don't need you to defend a grown man, and he doesn't either - he's proven he's tough, look at the line that he started behind for 15 games - almost got him killed. LITERALLY.