"Alex Smith makes your defense better"

[milkman]

Originally Posted by chiefzilla1501

He doesn't share some of the blame. He shares a really, really, really small % of the blame. So small that it's not even worth mentioning his name. A perfect QB performance is completely unreasonable, especially when you have to carry that kind of a team.

He left a total over 7 minutes on the play clock in the second half.

[RunKC]

Originally Posted by milkman

He left a total over 7 minutes on the play clock in the second half.

Link?

[milkman]

Originally Posted by RunKC

Link?

There is no link.

I did the math on my own a couple of months ago.

Posted it here.

[chiefzilla1501]

Originally Posted by milkman

He left a total over 7 minutes on the play clock in the second half.

I don't remember anything about clock management.

It still doesn't matter to me. You've got a guy who played at a hall of fame level save for a few mistakes, maybe including clock management. And in this case, I can't blame him for closing because he threw a good enough pass to set up a game winning field goal. So in the grand scheme of things, it's seems petty for people to even bring this game up as one of Smith's shortcomings. This is one of the few games in his career at KC that I thought we actually have a QB who can win some playoff games for us.

[milkman]

Originally Posted by chiefzilla1501

I don't remember anything about clock management.

It still doesn't matter to me. You've got a guy who played at a hall of fame level save for a few mistakes, maybe including clock management. And in this case, I can't blame him for closing because he threw a good enough pass to set up a game winning field goal. So in the grand scheme of things, it's seems petty for people to even bring this game up as one of Smith's shortcomings. This is one of the few games in his career at KC that I thought we actually have a QB who can win some playoff games for us.

If you don't remember anything about clock management then you were too stupid to notice.

When we traded for Smith, one of the things that his followers constantly poited out was his game smarts.

Not burning clock is not smart, and had he done so, there would not have been enough time for the Colts to score enough points tot come all the way back.

So, no, it's not petty.

That was a huge factor in allowing that comeback.

[chiefzilla1501]

Originally Posted by milkman

If you don't remember anything about clock management then you were too stupid to notice.

When we traded for Smith, one of the things that his followers constantly poited out was his game smarts.

Not burning clock is not smart, and had he done so, there would not have been enough time for the Colts to score enough points tot come all the way back.

So, no, it's not petty.

That was a huge factor in allowing that comeback.

Ok, I agree that he doesn't have in-game smarts. I've ragged on him a lot about that. It's still petty because you have to put those mistakes in context with the successes. And the blame here should be shared with Reid who could have easily put a stop to that shit. Smith still played a plus game and a plus second half. On the list of players to blame for the loss, he is probably one of the bottom of the list, which is rare to say for a QB.

I completely get what you're saying. If I was just talking to you, I'd agree. But there are people using things like that as an excuse to dig on Smith.