Travis Kelce is like a female version of Gronk

[ChiefAshhole1056]

Gronk (64) already has 5 more TDs than Witten (59)in their careers. Witten is considered by many to be a future H.O.Fer.

If both retired today, which one deserves it more? Witten is top 10 all-time in catches, but doesn't have any postseason success.

[Discuss Thrower]

Originally Posted by ChiefAshhole1056

Gronk (64) already has 5 more TDs than Witten (59)in their careers. Witten is considered by many to be a future H.O.Fer.

If both retired today, which one deserves it more? Witten is top 10 all-time in catches, but doesn't have any postseason success.

Brady has been a better QB than Romo and has demonstrated an ability to get production out of JAG players, so the edge goes to Witten in that aspect. Beside that, it's too early to compare Gronk with Witten given the age disparity.

Witten's comparison is Heath Miller. Gronk's current comp is Jimmy Graham? Maybe?

[PizzaDoughz]

Originally Posted by Discuss Thrower

Brady has been a better QB than Romo and has demonstrated an ability to get production out of JAG players, so the edge goes to Witten in that aspect. Beside that, it's too early to compare Gronk with Witten given the age disparity.

Witten's comparison is Heath Miller. Gronk's current comp is Jimmy Graham? Maybe?

Sure he gets production from the "JAGs," but it's not like he's had the GOAT TE level production before from a TE so this is just ridiculous. There's no point in this hypothetical because Gronk isn't going to retire today so what's the point? Besides Gronkowski is a much much better player and it's not even close, and there's the whole ring argument too, in which Gronk contributed greatly to achieve.