Which first-round playoff scenario do you prefer?

[BWillie]

Originally Posted by Rain Man

I haven't followed Indianapolis this year, but I have this impression that losing Andrew Luck has been a significant cause of their decline, and I have a vision of Andrew Luck charging from the tunnel in introductions and politely igniting the crowd and charging up his team, and then the NFL would fawn and gush and he would throw for 16 touchdowns in the most inspiring comeback since Rudy at Notre Dame recorded sacks on ten consecutive plays. And for the next 30 years of my life it would be replayed over and over and over on NFL Network, and the government would declare the first Sunday in January to be Andrew Luck Day.

I don't envision the same scenario with Bobby Hoyer.

Out of the 35 QBs qualified, Andrew Luck is 33rd out of 35 in QB Rating. I'll take my chances. Hasselback has a 84.0 QB rating, while Andrew Luck only has 79 QB Rating. He's one of the more overrated QBs out there. He's almost as bad as Peyton Manning this year, almost.