Do you Hope Foles Takes over the QB position ?

[TigeRRUppeRRcut]

Originally Posted by chiefzilla1501

What am I not comprehending? You called Alex Smith's 2012 season elite which means you're putting him in the class of Peyton, Brees, Brady, and Rodgers (who was elite that season). First of all... no. Second of all, if you're going to use QBR as some validation, you should acknowledge that tons of non-elite QBs like Palmer, Romo, Cousins, and in 2012 RGIII have posted top 5 QBRs.

Again, reading comprehension. Quarterbacks who have great seasons have just that... Playing at an elite level. Nobody said they were destined for the hall of fame and continue the trend.

[chiefzilla1501]

Originally Posted by TigerUppercut

Again, reading comprehension. Quarterbacks who have great seasons have just that... Playing at an elite level. Nobody said they were destined for the hall of fame and continue the trend.

Stats don't make you an elite QB, you dolt. If Alex Smith had an entire career like 2012, it still wouldn't make him an elite QB. The idea that QBR is the absolute measure of QB eliteness is totally ridiculous. Like I said, there are a lot of middling QBs who have ended up in the top 5 and it's not because they had elite seasons. It's because they had good stats for the year.