Should Mahomes be the starting QB tomorrow for the Bills game?

[TwistedChief]

Originally Posted by Hammock Parties

Are you ****ing kidding me?

Four of the last five games he's been butt****ing trash.

I think of the last five games he was solid in Oakland, average against Denver, and a cluster**** against Pittsburgh, Dallas, and NY.

But the games before that he was playing at a consistently higher level than he had in years past. I recall even you acknowledging that.

In aggregate, he's probably about the same QB as in prior years with higher highs and lower lows. If you want to read that optimistically, it means he's trying. If you want to read that pragmatically, he's trying but he can't make it work.

[Hammock Parties]

Originally Posted by TwistedChief

I think of the last five games he was solid in Oakland, average against Denver, and a cluster**** against Pittsburgh, Dallas, and NY.

But the games before that he was playing at a consistently higher level than he had in years past. I recall even you acknowledging that.

In aggregate, he's probably about the same QB as in prior years with higher highs and lower lows. If you want to read that optimistically, it means he's trying. If you want to read that pragmatically, he's trying but he can't make it work.

Only on CP is 14/31 "average."

The problem is that he is getting worse against inferior competition...he is done.

[TwistedChief]

Originally Posted by Hammock Parties

Only on CP is 14/31 "average."

The problem is that he is getting worse against inferior competition...he is done.

Meh. He's screened just as mediocre in past years against equally inferior competition and then bounced back to show traces of potential. I'm not willing to sell him this low nor was I ever willing to buy him earlier when CP was littered with delusional threads about our trading him for a 1st or 2nd round pick.