Josh Allen or Patrick Mahomes?

[Why Not?]

Originally Posted by smithandrew051

I might be forgetting someone, but by my count these are the only QBs with a winning record against Mahomes as a starter:

Jared Goff
Russell Wilson
Jacoby Brisett

Am I missing anyone? I’m going to assume that Mahomes will eventually have winning records against Goff and Wilson. Brisett probably won’t start another game against Mahomes, so he might end up as the only QB with a winning record against the GOAT. That’ll be a good trivia question some day.

Not sure about that. I’m not sure Goff is a starting QB in 3 seasons, let alone 7 which is how long he’d have to be (at least on the Rams) for PMII to get the 2 cracks he would need to have a winning record. Wilson certainly would be in 3 seasons but may be on the verge of hanging it up by 2027. And of course there would be no margin for error because lose one of those games and it’s 14 more years to have a shot to get over .500