8/2/22 Training Camp Discussion

[saphojunkie]

Originally Posted by ThaVirus

I have to assume you're talking about my take on Waters>Smith.

Waters was a two-time 1st team All-Pro. He was also the third best lineman on one of the top 3 best offensive lines of all time.

Trey Smith might be the third best OL on a unit that may not even be top 3 in the NFL this season.

I really don't think it's close at this point.



So is Trey Smith if we're arguing that he's on Brian Waters' level.

Trey Smith is a second year player. Taking an all pro at his zenith isn't a fair comparison, and I'd still say that "takes a shit" is excessive.