Do you believe that Pro Football Focus is any good at grading players?

[K9Texan]

Originally Posted by smithandrew051

I think their OL and DL grades are typically decent. Those are pretty straight forward to grade.

Their QB and skill position or back 7 grades are mostly useless. Those positions are just way too subjective.

QB especially. Unless you can sit down with the QB and Coach to discuss the play call and all that, you can never get the full context.

Also, a guy like Mahomes can get easy throws because he’s Mahomes. Teams have to respect everything he can do, which occasionally creates busts in the defense. How do you grade that?

Makes sense.