****The OFFICIAL Giants vs. Tony Romos! thread****

[Mecca]

Originally Posted by Bearcat

Not 'already better', but saying "let me know when Brodie wins a playoff game" is just as dumb as saying Croyle is without a doubt better than Eli.

I think the point is that Croyle's potential of throwing ~20 TDs and ~20 INTs with about 3,000 yard passing and a rating of 75 is pretty good. That's what Eli's done each of his first 4 years.

What's wrong with that statement?

I'll be surprised if he stays healthy enough to play enough games to get those stats.