Alright, let's settle this once and for all...

[BigRock]

Originally Posted by Mr. Arrowhead

olivo has thrown out 9 runners out of 19, when buck has thrown out 5 out of 38.

You can't consider that a more important stat than the team winning more games and the pitching staff having a better ERA with Buck in the game.

Originally Posted by Mr. Arrowhead

Also olivo has almost twice as many HRs

When they both have less than 10, "almost twice as many" is kinda misleading. Olivo has 4 more.

Originally Posted by Mr. Arrowhead

more RBi's, and a better batting avg.

Olivo does have a better batting average, but his OBP is .291. Buck's is .322.

The only stats in Olivo's favor are thrown-out base runners and the fact he has 4 more HRs and 1 more RBI. Absolutely everything else, including rather important ones like wins and ERA, point to Buck.

If the "stats don't lie", you're backing the wrong horse.