Curt Schilling Retires -- is he a HOFer?

[Amnorix]

Originally Posted by RJ

Mussina was a much more consistent pitcher than Schilling.

Also, you're forgetting that Mussina pitched on some really bad Orioles teams.

eh. The Orioles were average most of his years with them. Of course, he helped MAKE them average...

I think Mussina is pretty clearly in, however. I also can't quite fathom the Blyleven thing.

2000	Baltimore Orioles	American League	74	88	.457	13.5	3,297,031
1999	Baltimore Orioles	American League	78	84	.481	20.0	3,431,829
1998	Baltimore Orioles	American League	79	83	.488	35.0	3,685,194
1997	Baltimore Orioles	American League	98	64	.605	-	3,711,132
1996	Baltimore Orioles	American League	88	74	.543	4.0	3,646,950
1995	Baltimore Orioles	American League	71	73	.493	15.0	3,098,475
1994	Baltimore Orioles	American League	63	49	.563	6.5	2,535,359
1993	Baltimore Orioles	American League	85	77	.525	10.0	3,644,965
1992	Baltimore Orioles	American League	89	73	.549	7.0	3,567,819
1991	Baltimore Orioles	American League	67	95	.414	24.0	2,552,753