A case for Tyler Thigpen

[Just Passin' By]

Originally Posted by OnTheWarpath58

You know why?

All I've been told for the past 3 months is how important his experience is, and how sitting for years behind Brady makes him a can't miss veteran - how it made so much more sense to get him instead of drafting a young QB.

"Cassel can handle it, we'd ruin a young QB."

So the people are getting what they asked for.

You've been completely inconsistent with your arguments, all the while cherry picking comments from a few individuals rather than dealing with the general consensus about Cassel. Acting as if it's somehow others "getting what they asked for" is a steaming pile, nothing more.

Eli Manning is a franchise player according to you, but it's somehow unfair for others to point to Dilfer and Johnson in refuting that assertion because of career length? And you talk about the bullshit other posters have put down?

Was Marino a franchise QB?
Tarenton?
Fouts?
Jim Kelly?
Jay Schroeder?
Doug Williams?
Ken Stabler?

Do you have a full list of the NFL's franchise QBs since, say, 1970?

And the 3 months thing is just another load of bullshit. You've been blowing Sanchez and pounding on Cassel since before that 3 month period even started.