A little thank you to Warren Buffet

[Rain Man]

Originally Posted by Amnorix

You're not the only one on GE, and you're talking to a guy who has bought into MAYBE 12 or so different individual stocks in his life. I'm starting to do more now, though, just because. Slow and steady wins the race, but it is damn boring. I'm finally at a point where I"m comfortable making fairly small plays on my own, so sure.

But yes, GE was one of my early ones, and it has been a problem for a while. It's finally gotten to the plus side of the ledger, however, thank goodness.

I'm terrible at selling, so I'm probably going to implement your system, or a variant of it. I watched Alcoa go waaay up and then come all the way back down to negative. I think I was up 100% at one point, but now I'm at +3%. Your system seems like the kind of thing I need to enforce some kind of discipline on myself. Otherwise, I tend to buy and hold forever.

But I'm never going to hold onto shares that are up 20% after a merger/acquisition is announced.

Your Alcoa example is another reason why I implemented this system. I too have had a few stocks that have had a really good run, and then it frustrated me to see it drop back down. I set the 20 percent threshold because I figure it's low enough that a stock could have a good run and go up that far and then drop back down within a short period of time. If I get that return and then eliminate the risk to my initial capital, then I'm willing to take the risk that it'll cool down if my only downside is losing profit.

The other side of my equation was that, in an Alcoa type of situation, I would buy back the original shares if the price dropped back down to the original purchase price. I haven't had the discipline to do that yet because I've always found another shiny stock beforehand, but in theory it seems like it should work. Ride the stock up, sell the original investment amount high, and then just invest it right back if it goes back down. If it keeps going up you still get a little piece of the action with the profit that you've left in it.

The model only seems to break down when you buy GE and it gets on a train south and never comes back.

[Amnorix]

Originally Posted by Rain Man

Your Alcoa example is another reason why I implemented this system. I too have had a few stocks that have had a really good run, and then it frustrated me to see it drop back down. I set the 20 percent threshold because I figure it's low enough that a stock could have a good run and go up that far and then drop back down within a short period of time. If I get that return and then eliminate the risk to my initial capital, then I'm willing to take the risk that it'll cool down if my only downside is losing profit.

Well, I've implemented your plan already. I had Pfizer bought at $17 and it's at $27, or up 55% or so, and I'd arbitrarily decided to sell at $30/share, which it's been slowing climbing toward for awhile. Instead, I have now sold 2/3rds of my shares, which is enough to get my initial investment back, and am holding onto the 1/3rd as a profit play.

Your take the money off teh table approach makes sense. Of course, lately it hasn't been too tough to get a 20% gain on anything if you were buying anytime after the '08 crash...

In a bear market, finding somethimg to go up 20% is a helluva lot harder.

[Rain Man]

Originally Posted by Amnorix

Well, I've implemented your plan already. I had Pfizer bought at $17 and it's at $27, or up 55% or so, and I'd arbitrarily decided to sell at $30/share, which it's been slowing climbing toward for awhile. Instead, I have now sold 2/3rds of my shares, which is enough to get my initial investment back, and am holding onto the 1/3rd as a profit play.

Your take the money off teh table approach makes sense. Of course, lately it hasn't been too tough to get a 20% gain on anything if you were buying anytime after the '08 crash...

In a bear market, finding somethimg to go up 20% is a helluva lot harder.

Yeah, that's what has made evaluation hard. Looking back, I started this system in 2006 and ramped it up in earnest in 2007 and 2008. I think I might've moved one stock in 2009 and 2010. Brutal, just brutal.

Let me know how it works for you.