Chiefs Manning or Orton? - Page 5

Titty Meat · 12-19-2011, 03:34 AM

Let's assume the Chiefs win another game or 2 putting them further back in the draft order. We know it's unlikely they will trade up to draft a QB as their past is well documented on here. Say you're the GM would you A. Re-sign Orton or B. Enter the Peyton Manning sweepstakes (guessing Manning will most likely be released and become a free agent).

Rexx · 12-19-2011, 01:18 PM

Why would you take Orton over Manning? Chiefs have the cap space if they decide they want to go for Manning. He has a few years left and would have no issue with them going that route. IMO, they would be legitimate Super Bowl contenders assuming Manning is injury free.

whoman69 · 12-19-2011, 01:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Phobia

The only way I'm interested in Manning is if he's coming here to mentor our 1st round QB for 2 years and is given a clean bill of health.

I would add a restructured contract and a reasonable amount we have to give up. If we have to give up our cap space and our future for Manning, there's no point.

Okie_Apparition · 12-19-2011, 01:25 PM

Pioli knew all that mattered in the 2009 draft, was to draft an Adam Vinatieri. For when he latter picked up Brady or Manning

Ryan Succup is in da house

kaplin42 · 12-19-2011, 01:33 PM

Manning will not come to the Chiefs. He will stay and mentor Luck on the Colts, or retire. He has nothing to prove and has butt loads of cash. No reason to even dream of that. On top of that, stop being part of the problem by wanting over-paid end of career broken down vets to come to KC for one final payday.

I say we have Orton, draft a young QB and keep Orton as a mentor.

On the topic of Orton, while he is leaps and bounds beyond Cassel and Palko, lets know superglue his nuts to our chin just yet. He is average at best, it's just we are so starved for remotely competent QB play that he was just a joy to watch yesterday.

For trading up in the draft, now with the rookie salary cap, trades will happen again, as the financial risk of paying a top tiered rookie has been greatly reduced.

Okie_Apparition · 12-19-2011, 01:38 PM

I think Peyton is a media whore that loves him some limelight. If he can, he'll play & the endorsements will follow him anywhere he goes. Even retirement

ShowtimeSBMVP · 12-19-2011, 02:27 PM

adbrandtAndrew Brandt

Again, Manning cannot be traded due to timing of option. RT @haha1721 u think cowboys would go after manning? Trade romo?

adbrandtAndrew Brandt

Yes with Peyton having all the leverage. RT @DickBrianEsq can they renegotiate the option date?

No way he helps the colts out

Frankie · 12-19-2011, 02:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Okie_Apparition

Indy needs to rebuild & I doubt the offense under Manning is the same as they'd have for Luck
that 28+ million for Peyton's salary could buy some nice toys

Unless their GM is Scott Pioli and their owner, Clark Hunt.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rexx

Why would you take Orton over Manning? Chiefs have the cap space if they decide they want to go for Manning. He has a few years left and would have no issue with them going that route. IMO, they would be legitimate Super Bowl contenders assuming Manning is injury free.

Because I don't believe Manning's neck is as healthy or durable as the Colts want you to believe.

12-19-2011, 03:34 AM
Titty Meat Inmem 2.0 Join Date: Aug 2007 Location: My house Casino cash: $2147558	Manning or Orton? Let's assume the Chiefs win another game or 2 putting them further back in the draft order. We know it's unlikely they will trade up to draft a QB as their past is well documented on here. Say you're the GM would you A. Re-sign Orton or B. Enter the Peyton Manning sweepstakes (guessing Manning will most likely be released and become a free agent).
Posts: 75,280

12-19-2011, 01:18 PM	#61
Rexx Seeing Red! Join Date: Aug 2001 Location: NM, USA Casino cash: $10005814	Why would you take Orton over Manning? Chiefs have the cap space if they decide they want to go for Manning. He has a few years left and would have no issue with them going that route. IMO, they would be legitimate Super Bowl contenders assuming Manning is injury free.
Posts: 204

12-19-2011, 01:25 PM	#63
Okie_Apparition Banned Join Date: Jan 2011 Location: floatin cobwebs n the sky Casino cash: $10004900	Pioli knew all that mattered in the 2009 draft, was to draft an Adam Vinatieri. For when he latter picked up Brady or Manning Ryan Succup is in da house
Posts: 7,012

12-19-2011, 01:33 PM	#64
kaplin42 Thats Right, Sniff the Glue!!! Join Date: Jun 2004 Location: tubbytronic superdome Casino cash: $10007177	Manning will not come to the Chiefs. He will stay and mentor Luck on the Colts, or retire. He has nothing to prove and has butt loads of cash. No reason to even dream of that. On top of that, stop being part of the problem by wanting over-paid end of career broken down vets to come to KC for one final payday. I say we have Orton, draft a young QB and keep Orton as a mentor. On the topic of Orton, while he is leaps and bounds beyond Cassel and Palko, lets know superglue his nuts to our chin just yet. He is average at best, it's just we are so starved for remotely competent QB play that he was just a joy to watch yesterday. For trading up in the draft, now with the rookie salary cap, trades will happen again, as the financial risk of paying a top tiered rookie has been greatly reduced.
Posts: 3,469

12-19-2011, 01:38 PM	#65
Okie_Apparition Banned Join Date: Jan 2011 Location: floatin cobwebs n the sky Casino cash: $10004900	I think Peyton is a media whore that loves him some limelight. If he can, he'll play & the endorsements will follow him anywhere he goes. Even retirement
Posts: 7,012

12-19-2011, 02:27 PM	#66
ShowtimeSBMVP Chiefs Join Date: Feb 2009 Casino cash: $3546009	adbrandtAndrew Brandt Again, Manning cannot be traded due to timing of option. RT @haha1721 u think cowboys would go after manning? Trade romo? adbrandtAndrew Brandt Yes with Peyton having all the leverage. RT @DickBrianEsq can they renegotiate the option date? No way he helps the colts out
Posts: 23,755