Elite QB's: I'm There Says Matt Cassel

[milkman]

Originally Posted by chiefsfootballfan

eh. he was a freak football helmet catch from disaster. he was painful to watch those first years, but he really impressed that first playoff run to the championship. the dallas game then GB. he hasn't been consistent enough to be better than peyton but he will likely become a HOF player and continue to become more solid. he has a better arm than peyton, but not quite the accuracy and to me, that's where his inconsistency was earlier.

What everyone forgets about that play is that ball was a well thrown ball, after Eli Manning escaped from a near certain sack and great pressure to make, that David Tyree bobbled to make it look more difficult to catch than it should have been.

Eli Manning's play in the pocket was the more impressive play on that play than Tyree's circus catch that should have been an easy catch to make.