Elite QB's: I'm There Says Matt Cassel

[Ace Gunner]

Originally Posted by Dylan

No, it wasn't a "freak football helmet catch from disaster" - If Tyree had dropped the ball - It was only third down.

I don't know how Eli can be "more solid!"

Eli has emerged as the Giants best-ever quarterback.



He's solid rock.

I really like the Giants new Super Bowl ring. I hope the Chiefs get one soon!

eli's first 4 seasons were worse than matt cassel's first 4 seasons, both stat wise and play on the field imo. those were at least as bad as matt cassel games during the first years eli took over.

phil simms started out bad too.

when we look at it this way, it's hard to argue matt cassel couldn't turn into a decent QB. but no. I don't think cassel has the skillsets, the mechanics etc... he's a baseball player moonlighting.